Problems solved in full
-
Thirteen days between New York's earliest sunset and shortest day in 2026 6 steps
New York's shortest day in 2026 is 21 December, and its earliest sunset falls on 8 December. Where do those thirteen days come from, and does every latitude have them?
-
Sunset is solar noon plus half the day. Solar noon in clock time is 720 − 4λ − E + 60Z minutes after midnight, with λ the longitude east, Z the standard-time offset and E the equation of time. Neither λ nor Z changes through the year, so only two quantities can move sunset: E, and the day length D.
-
Take the three weeks before the solstice. The tool puts solar noon at 11:45 on 1 December and 11:54 on 21 December, which is 705.1 and 714.2 minutes after midnight. Noon has slipped 9.1 minutes later, and the only term in it that moves is the equation of time, falling from +10.92 min to +1.84 min.
-
Across those same weeks the day shortens from 568.4 to 555.0 minutes, which the tool shows as 9h 28m and 9h 15m. Sunset carries half of that change, so it loses 6.7 minutes.
-
Add the two. Sunset moves 2.4 minutes later, from 989.3 to 991.7 minutes after midnight, over three weeks in which the day got 13.3 minutes shorter.
-
The turning point is the date where the two rates cancel. On 8 December dE/dn is −0.441 minutes per day and half of dD/dn is −0.433, near enough equal, and the tool prints sunset at 16:28 with a day of 9h 21m. That is the earliest sunset of the year.
-
Now every latitude at once. D depends on latitude, but its change through the year is driven by the declination alone, and the declination is stationary at a solstice, so dD/dn all but vanishes there whatever your latitude. What is left is dt/dn = −dE/dn, which is +0.497 minutes per day on 21 December and carries no latitude in it. Swept from 66° S to 66° N in hundredths of a degree the real rate runs from +0.497 at the equator to +0.411 at the ends, never turning negative, so the earliest sunset lands on the December solstice at none of those latitudes. The argument frays exactly where "all but vanishes" stops being true. At 65.72° N on the June solstice the day is 23h 47m long, and two hundredths of a degree further north it is a full 24 h; there dD/dn is not negligible at all, and sunset really is getting earlier, by 0.11 minutes a day. That band is a few hundredths of a degree wide.
Answer
16:28 on 8 December, thirteen days ahead of the solstice, because the equation of time outruns the change in day length. The tool shows one place at a time; the last step covers all of them.
-
-
A sundial 16 minutes fast, measured in kilometres 6 steps
On 3 November, with the clock kept on GMT, London’s solar noon falls at 11:44. Work out how far east you would have to move for a mean-time clock to agree with the sundial, then decide whether a sundial could ever have found longitude at sea.
-
Solar noon is mean noon shifted by two things, and only one of them matters here. London sits within a thousandth of a degree of the meridian, so the whole displacement is the equation of time, which the panel prints as +16.46 minutes.
-
Time and longitude are one quantity in two units, at a rate the Earth’s rotation fixes: a full turn in 1,440 minutes.
-
The sundial’s lead is therefore worth 4.11° of longitude. A clock kept on mean time at that longitude strikes noon exactly when a London sundial does.
-
In ground distance, at London’s latitude, that is 285 km east.
-
And it reverses. The equation of time bottoms out at −14.18 minutes on 11 February, so across a year the sundial swings 30.64 minutes, which is 7.66° of longitude.
-
At the equator that swing is 853 km, and a single minute of clock error is 27.8 km. Those two numbers are why the equation of time is tabulated in every almanac rather than waved away.
Answer
4.11° east, about 285 km. The equation of time is a correction rather than an obstacle: it is tabulated, and a dial read to the minute and corrected gives local apparent time to a quarter of a degree, 28 km at the equator. What no dial supplies is the other half of the sum. Longitude is the difference between local time and the time at an agreed place, and a sundial only ever knows that it is noon here. That is why the answer to the longitude problem was a clock that carries the reference, and not a better dial.
-