Problem solved in full
-
Recession speed when a galaxy's hydrogen-alpha line sits at 660.00 nm 6 steps
A galaxy's hydrogen-alpha line sits at 660.00 nm instead of 656.28 nm. Find its recession speed properly, and settle whether the schoolbook v = cz is good enough here — and where it stops being good enough.
-
Redshift is defined as the fractional change in wavelength, and it is the only measured quantity on this page. Everything below is arithmetic on it.
-
The relativistic Doppler formula for a source moving directly away combines the classical shift with time dilation. Invert it for β — squaring both sides makes the rearrangement a single line.
-
Substitute. The numerator is essentially 2z and the denominator essentially 2, which is why the answer is so close to z at small redshift, and why the agreement has to break down once z² stops being negligible.
-
Multiply by c both ways and compare. The 4.8 km/s gap is far smaller than the peculiar velocity of a galaxy in a cluster, so at this redshift the choice of formula is not the limiting error.
-
Push z upward and the two diverge. The classical expression has no ceiling; the relativistic one has β → 1 built into its algebra.
-
One more step turns the speed into a distance. Hubble's law with H₀ = 70 km/s/Mpc puts this galaxy about 24 Mpc away — a long way outside the Local Group, and a distance nothing else in the measurement could have supplied.
Answer
1694.501 km/s, against 1699.317 km/s from v = cz — a 0.28% overstatement. At this redshift the shortcut is harmless. It stays harmless for a while and then fails abruptly: at z = 0.1 it is 5.2% high, and at z = 1 it returns exactly c, which is not a large error but an impossible answer. The relativistic form cannot do that, because β = ((1+z)²−1)/((1+z)²+1) approaches 1 from below no matter how large z becomes. Feed it z = 5 and it returns 0.946c; feed the shortcut z = 5 and it returns five times the speed of light.
-
References (1)
- The relativistic treatment this tool uses rather than the classical shortcut — the Doppler section is §7: A. Einstein, "Zur Elektrodynamik bewegter Körper." Annalen der Physik 322, 891–921, 1905.