Problems solved in full
-
36 and 29 solar masses at 440 Mpc 6 steps
36 and 29 solar masses at 440 Mpc. Find the chirp mass, how long the signal lasts, and how far LIGO's mirrors actually move — then find the one number on the panel that does not depend on any of the inputs.
-
Two masses enter the waveform in only one combination, and this is it. The chirp mass is what a detector measures directly — the individual masses have to be teased out later, from the part of the signal this formula cannot see.
-
Time to merger scales as the chirp mass to the −5/3 and the entry frequency to the −8/3. Both exponents are large, so both inputs matter far more than they look.
-
The innermost stable circular orbit is where the inspiral has to stop, and its frequency goes inversely with total mass: a heavier binary merges at a lower pitch. At 65 solar masses that is 68 Hz — near the bottom of LIGO's band, which is why this event was heard as a thump rather than a chirp.
-
Strain is dimensionless: it is the fractional stretch of space. Multiply by the arm length to get a distance.
-
Put that distance beside something. A proton is 8.4 × 10⁻¹⁶ m across its charge radius, and the mirrors moved by less than a hundredth of that.
-
Now the row that never changes. Nothing about the binary survives into it — this is a ceiling, not a measurement.
Answer
The luminosity, and it is c⁵/5G. Every other row moves when you touch a slider; that one is 1.90 × 10²⁵ L☉ whatever the masses, the distance or the starting frequency, because it is built from the speed of light and the gravitational constant and nothing else. It is the largest power any process in general relativity can radiate, and for a few milliseconds this merger was putting out more of it than every star in the observable universe puts out in light. The other end of the scale is on the same panel: 1.16 × 10⁻²¹ of strain across LIGO's 4 km arms is a length change of 4.6 × 10⁻¹⁸ m, which is a 181st of the radius of a proton. Both numbers describe the same event.
-
-
Two neutron stars of 1.4 solar masses each at 100 Mpc 5 steps
Two neutron stars of 1.4 solar masses each, at 100 Mpc. Predict every row from the black-hole answer above without recomputing anything, using only the exponents.
-
Recompute only the chirp mass. For equal masses it collapses to 2−1/5 times the common mass, which is 1.22 for a pair of 1.4s.
-
Everything else is a ratio. The duration exponent is −5/3, so form the mass ratio first and raise it once.
-
Apply it to the 0.843 s from the previous problem. No integral, no constants, no formula beyond the exponent.
-
The ISCO frequency is inversely proportional to total mass, so the same trick with a much smaller exponent gives the pitch at the end.
-
Strain carries two dependencies at once — up with chirp mass to the 5/3, down with distance — and this pair is both lighter and nearer, so the effects partly cancel.
Answer
The whole difference is one power law: 187. The chirp mass drops from 28.10 to 1.22, and because the inspiral time scales as ℳ−5/3, dividing by 23 in mass multiplies the time by 235/3 = 187. That turns 0.84 seconds into 157, which is why a neutron-star merger is the one LIGO can announce while it is still happening — 2.6 minutes is long enough to point telescopes, and GW170817 is why anyone saw the kilonova. The same lever works against you at the other end: fISCO goes as 1/M, so the merger finishes at 1570 Hz, well above where the detectors are most sensitive. Light binaries are easy to hear coming and hard to hear arrive.
-
References (3)
- The detection the first block describes, and its measured strain: B. P. Abbott et al. (LIGO Scientific Collaboration and Virgo Collaboration), "Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Merger." Physical Review Letters 116(6), 061102, 2016.
- The neutron-star merger behind the gw170817 preset: B. P. Abbott et al., "GW170817: Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Neutron Star Inspiral." Physical Review Letters 119(16), 161101, 2017.
- The chirp-mass and peak-strain expressions the tool evaluates: M. Maggiore, Gravitational Waves, Volume 1: Theory and Experiments, §4.1. Oxford University Press, 2008. ISBN 978-0-19-857074-5.