Problem solved in full
-
Limit where something can still orbit Earth rather than the Sun 5 steps
How far from Earth can something still orbit Earth rather than being taken by the Sun — and is the Moon safely inside that limit? Earth: m = 5.972 × 10²⁴ kg, a = 1 AU, e = 0.0167. Sun: M = 1.989 × 10³⁰ kg.
-
The Hill radius is where a planet’s pull on a small body matches the Sun’s tidal tug at that distance. The cube root is the signature of that balance: it is a ratio of a mass to a mass, taken to the one-third power because gravity falls as an inverse square while the tidal term does not.
-
Work out the mass ratio first — this is the quantity the calculator above prints as “mass ratio”, and note it is m/3M, not m/M.
-
Take the cube root. Notice how brutally the cube root compresses: a millionth becomes a hundredth, so Earth’s sphere of influence is about one hundredth of its distance from the Sun even though Earth is a millionth of the Sun’s mass.
-
Multiply by the perihelion distance — the tightest point of the orbit, because that is where the Sun competes hardest and so where the limit is smallest.
-
Now test the Moon against it. Prograde orbits are only stable out to roughly half the Hill radius, so that is the line the Moon has to beat.
Answer
1.472 × 10⁶ km, and the Moon at 3.84 × 10⁵ km sits at 0.26 of it — comfortably inside even the stricter half-Hill limit for prograde orbits. The cube root is why this works at all: it is such a compressive function that a planet a millionth of its star’s mass still commands a region one hundredth as wide as its orbit. It is also why capture is rare and why distant irregular moons are all retrograde — retrograde orbits stay stable out to about 0.7 rH, further than prograde ones.
-
References (2)
- Insight block 3 — why retrograde moons stay bound farther out: D. P. Hamilton and J. A. Burns, "Orbital stability zones about asteroids. II. The destabilizing effects of eccentric orbits and of solar radiation." Icarus 96(1), 43–64, 1992.
- R. C. Domingos, O. C. Winter and T. Yokoyama, "Stable satellites around extrasolar giant planets." Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 373(3), 1227–1234, 2006 — the same asymmetry measured for close-in giants.