Problem solved in full
-
Two standard answers for where Earth's gravity stops winning 5 steps
Where does Earth's gravity stop winning against the Sun's? There are two standard answers, they differ by 62%, and both are correct. Work out both and find what separates them.
-
Everything depends on one number, the mass ratio, and it is small: Earth is about a three-hundred-thousandth of the Sun.
-
The first answer is the patched-conic sphere of influence, and its exponent is 2/5. It marks where switching your calculation from heliocentric to geocentric introduces least error โ a statement about approximation quality, not about force.
-
The second is the Hill radius, with an exponent of 1/3. It marks where a small third body can stay in orbit indefinitely โ a statement about stability, in the rotating frame where centrifugal terms matter.
-
The two exponents are what make the answers differ, and 1.619 is the ratio between them.
-
The Moon settles the practical question: at 384 400 km it sits at 42% of the sphere of influence, comfortably inside both, which is why it is Earth's moon and not a second planet.
Answer
The tool prints 0.006181 AU for the sphere of influence, 0.01000 AU for the Hill radius, and a ratio of 1.619. The point is that neither is the boundary โ they answer different questions, and using the wrong one is a real navigational error. A mission planner switching reference frames wants the 2/5 figure; someone asking whether a captured asteroid will stay captured wants the 1/3 one. Objects between the two radii are in the awkward band: bound enough to orbit for a while, not bound enough to stay. That is roughly where distant irregular satellites live, and why they are so easily lost.
-
References (1)
- The patched-conic method that makes the SOI boundary useful, and its limits: R. R. Bate, D. D. Mueller and J. E. White, Fundamentals of Astrodynamics, ยง7.4. Dover, 1971. ISBN 978-0-486-60061-1.