Problem solved in full
-
The Sun's total power from its size and surface temperature 5 steps
Work out the Sun's total power from nothing but its size and its surface temperature, then use that single number to predict how cold Earth ought to be. This is the tool's Sun state: R = 1 R☉ = 6.957 × 108 m, T = 5772 K, ε = 1.
-
Stefan-Boltzmann gives power per square metre, so the count of square metres has to come first. A star radiates from its photosphere, and a sphere's area needs only the radius.
-
Now the flux from one square metre. The fourth power is what makes this law so unforgiving: a star only 20% hotter than the Sun radiates 1.204 = 2.07 times as hard from every patch of its surface.
-
Luminosity is flux times area and nothing else, because every photon that leaves the star crosses that surface exactly once. The result is the definition of one solar luminosity, which is why the tool's comparison row reads 1.
-
Leave the star. The same power now spreads over a sphere whose radius is Earth's distance, so only the area in the denominator changes. Satellites above the atmosphere measure 1361 W/m2, and that agreement is the check on all three steps above.
-
Earth intercepts sunlight across a disc of area πR⊕2 but radiates from its entire sphere, 4πR⊕2. The planet's radius cancels, the factor of 4 does not, and clouds and ice reflect roughly 30% straight back out before any of it is absorbed.
Answer
The tool prints 6.082 × 1018 m2, 6.294 × 107 W/m2 and 3.828 × 1026 W. Everything after that is the same law used twice more, and it ends at 254.6 K. Earth's actual mean surface temperature is 288 K, so the prediction is wrong by 33 K, and it is wrong in a specific direction: too cold, always. That gap is the greenhouse effect, and it is the one quantity in the chain that σT4 cannot supply, because the law describes what a surface radiates and says nothing about what the air above it does with the radiation on the way out. A calculation this crude landing within 12% of a planet is the reason it is the first thing anyone computes about an exoplanet.
-
References (3)
- Betelgeuse’s radius and temperature, the preset behind the first block: M. Joyce et al., "Standing on the Shoulders of Giants: New Mass and Distance Estimates for Betelgeuse through Combined Evolutionary, Asteroseismic, and Hydrodynamic Simulations with MESA." The Astrophysical Journal 902(1), 63, 2020.
- The solar radius, luminosity and temperature the tool normalises to: A. Prša et al., "Nominal Values for Selected Solar and Planetary Quantities: IAU 2015 Resolution B3." The Astronomical Journal 152(2), 41, 2016.
- The value of σ: E. Tiesinga, P. J. Mohr, D. B. Newell and B. N. Taylor, "CODATA recommended values of the fundamental physical constants: 2018." Reviews of Modern Physics 93(2), 025010, 2021.