Problem solved in full
-
Cycle of how often Jupiter and Saturn line up 5 steps
Jupiter's year is 4332.59 days and Saturn's is 10759.22. Find how often the two line up, where in the sky each meeting falls, and then a far slower cycle hiding in the same two numbers. This is the Jupiter-Saturn state, with the alignment target set to the same relative longitude.
-
Periods do not subtract; rates do. Converting each period into turns per day is what makes the rest of this arithmetic rather than geometry.
-
Two runners on a circular track meet again when the faster has gained exactly one whole lap, so the meeting rate is the difference of the lap rates. Subtracting two small numbers leaves a smaller one, which is how a 12-year planet and a 29-year planet end up on a 20-year clock β slower than either of them.
-
One Jupiter year does not finish the job, and the shortfall is large. In 4332.59 days Saturn covers 40% of its own orbit, so the alignment has slipped by more than half a turn and Jupiter must chase it for another two thirds of a lap.
-
Now ask where the meeting happens, not only when. Jupiter completes 1.674 of its own orbits per cycle, and it is the fractional part that walks the conjunction round the sky β each one lands 117.3Β° behind the last. Three of them very nearly close a triangle.
-
The period ratio is the clue to the second cycle. A ratio close to a simple fraction means some whole-number combination of the two rates is nearly zero, and 5/2 is the fraction this pair is closest to. Two of Jupiter's turns against five of Saturn's leaves about a thousandth of a degree a day.
Answer
The tool prints a synodic period of 7253.4577 days, 19.8589 years, a slip of 215.0329Β° per Jupiter orbit and a period ratio of 2.4833. What follows is Kepler's: successive great conjunctions step 117.3Β° round the zodiac, three of them return to within 8.1Β° of the start after 59.6 years, and that slowly turning triangle needs 221 years to walk a single sign. The 2.4833 hides more than the 20-year beat. Because it sits 0.7% from 5/2, the combination 2Ξ»J β 5Ξ»S creeps at 0.0011160Β° a day, a cycle of 883 years β the Great Inequality that made Jupiter appear to speed up and Saturn to slow down throughout recorded observation, until Laplace showed in 1785 that both would turn round. A calculator that only ever forms |n1 β n2| finds the 20-year cycle and is blind to the 883-year one: a near-resonance puts a beat at every small-integer combination of the two rates, not only at their difference.
-
References (1)
- The commensurability behind insight block 3: J. Kepler, Harmonices Mundi, Book V. Linz, 1619 β the ratios between planetary periods, including the VenusβEarth near-commensurability the pentagram comes from.