Problem solved in full
-
Tisserand parameter for an object with respect to Jupiter 5 steps
An object with a = 3.3 AU, e = 0.5, i = 12° has a Tisserand parameter of 2.926 with respect to Jupiter. Work it out, and then find why the value 3 is the number that matters.
-
The parameter combines three orbital elements into one quantity that a Jupiter encounter leaves almost unchanged — which is what makes it useful, since an encounter changes a, e and i individually by a great deal.
-
The first term is the ratio of Jupiter's semi-major axis to the object's, and it is the larger contribution here.
-
The second needs the orbital factor, which folds the eccentricity in through a square root, then the inclination through a cosine.
-
Together they give 2.926.
-
The threshold comes from putting Jupiter's own orbit into the formula: a = ap, e = 0, i = 0 gives 1 + 2 = 3 exactly. So 3 is not a convention, it is what the expression returns for an object sharing Jupiter's orbit.
Answer
The tool prints 1.5770, 0.6896, 1.3491 and a Tisserand parameter of 2.9261. Below 3 means the orbit can cross Jupiter's and be scattered by it, which is the standard dividing line between Jupiter-family comets and asteroids — and it is a better one than composition or appearance, because it survives the encounters that scramble everything else. That is the whole reason the quantity exists: it is nearly conserved, so it labels an object's dynamical family rather than its current orbit. A dormant comet that has lost its tail still gives itself away here.
-
References (3)
- The Öpik relation U² = 3 − T that makes 3 a physical boundary: G. B. Valsecchi, A. Milani, G. F. Gronchi and S. R. Chesley, "Resonant returns to close approaches: Analytical theory." Astronomy & Astrophysics 408(3), 1179–1196, 2003.
- The parameter used to sort short-period comet orbits: H. F. Levison and M. J. Duncan, "The Long-Term Dynamical Behavior of Short-Period Comets." Icarus 108(1), 18–36, 1994.
- The original close-encounter treatment: E. J. Öpik, Interplanetary Encounters: Close-Range Gravitational Interactions. Elsevier, 1976.