Lesson
The theory — Rearranging Formulas331 words
Making a letter the subject means producing an equivalent formula with that letter alone on one side. Whether it can be done divides into two questions that look identical from the outside: whether this method can do it, and whether anything can.
What each symbol means
subject- the letter you are isolating. Which one it is changes the difficulty completely; the formula does not care, but the algebra does.
±- what an even root hands back — two candidates and no way to choose between them from the algebra alone.
- Assumes
- That every operation between you and the subject can be undone one at a time from the outside in. That holds exactly when the letter occurs once.
- Breaks when
- In two quite different places, and telling them apart is the point. The method runs out when the letter occurs more than once:
s = ut + ½at²defeats peeling, and the page says so. But that formula is a quadratic in t and a different method solves it exactly — withu = 3,a = 2,s = 20the answer ist = 3.216991, and putting it back returns 20.000000. Nothing is unsolvable there; peeling is simply the wrong method for it. The equation itself resists in Kepler’sM = E − e sin E, where E sits both on its own and inside a sine, so no finite run of algebraic operations on M and e will ever isolate it. That one is not stuck: Lagrange and Bessel give it as a series, and Bessel functions were invented for the coefficients. What the series has instead is a boundary. It converges only for eccentricities below the Laplace limit,0.662743419349— and Halley’s comet, ate = 0.967, is outside it. So the honest answer to “can this be rearranged?” has three levels: this method cannot, another method can; no method can, but a series can; and the series has a range.
Problems solved in full
-
The radius when the area of a circle is 78.54 cm² 7 steps
The area of a circle is 78.54 cm². Find the radius — and say precisely where the algebra stops and you start.
-
Start from the formula as given, with A the subject and r buried inside a square.
-
Peel from the outside. The outermost operation applied to r is the multiplication by π, so divide both sides by π first.
-
Now the square. Undoing it is the step where one input stops giving one output, which is why the line carries a ± rather than a bare root.
-
The ± is doing real work: +5 and −5 both square to 25, so both are correct solutions of the equation r² = 25. The equation does not know what r means.
-
Substituting the number in: r = ±5 cm, and 5 is the answer because a radius is a length. That sentence is not algebra. It is the only step in the whole problem that required knowing what the letters stand for.
-
Check by going forwards, which is the only check worth doing: put 5 back into the original formula and see whether the area comes back.
-
And notice what would change in a different dress. The same equation h² = 25 for a height above and below a line keeps both answers; the same equation t² = 25 for a time keeps −5 only if the clock started somewhere else. The algebra is identical in all three. The discarding is not.
Answer
r = 5 cm. The algebra gives ±5 and stops there, correctly. Choosing 5 is a statement about radii, and it is the one step in the problem that the formula could not have made for you.
-
-
Fahrenheit as the subject, and the reading both scales agree on 6 steps
Make F the subject of C = 5(F − 32)/9 and check it on boiling water. Then decide whether a thermometer can ever show the same number on both scales.
-
F is buried three deep: inside a bracket, inside a multiplication by 5, inside a division by 9. Peel from the outside, so the 9 comes off first.
-
Multiply both sides by 9, then divide by 5. Two of the three moves, and neither has touched the bracket.
-
Add 32 and F stands alone. Three moves, which is what the panel counts, and the check card puts 100 °C back through the rearranged formula and gets 212.
-
Now the question this method refuses. Asking where the two scales read the same means setting F = C, which puts the letter on both sides. That is the situation the tool stops at, because there is nothing left to peel toward.
-
Here both occurrences are linear, so they collect into one and the peeling starts again. The answer is −40, and it checks: 9(−40)/5 + 32 is −72 + 32.
-
The same collection answers the general version. Fahrenheit is double Celsius at 160 °C, which is 320 °F. At k = 1.8 the denominator vanishes and there is no answer, because the two lines are parallel and Fahrenheit runs 32 ahead of 1.8 × Celsius for ever.
Answer
F = 9C/5 + 32, and the two scales agree at −40. Three moves turn the formula round, and the panel confirms it by sending 100 °C back to 212 °F. The fixed point needs a fourth move the tool does not offer: collect the two Cs. That works only because both are linear, which is the whole difference between this and the displacement formula the tool declines.
-
Learning path
Solving for x, from the minus sign upward
References (1)
- The series that solves what peeling cannot, and the eccentricity at which it stops: P. Colwell, "Bessel Functions and Kepler's Equation." The American Mathematical Monthly 99:1 (1992), 45–48.