Problem solved in full
-
Recession speed when hydrogen's Hα line arrives at 721.6 nm 5 steps
Hydrogen's Hα line leaves a galaxy at 656 nm and arrives at 721.6 nm. Find the recession speed. The obvious formula is out by about 1500 km/s here, and at higher redshift it fails outright.
-
Redshift is defined as the fractional stretch of the wavelength, so it reads straight off the two numbers. z = 0.1: the light arrived 10% redder than it left.
-
The formula almost everyone reaches for is v = cz, inherited from the low-speed Doppler shift. It returns 29 979 km/s, a tenth of light speed.
-
But a tenth of light speed is not low speed. The relativistic Doppler relation ties 1 + z to a square root of (1 + β)/(1 − β); solving for β takes one line of algebra and gives 0.09502, not 0.1.
-
That is 28 487 km/s. The naive figure overstates it by 5.2% — roughly 1500 km/s, which is larger than the velocity differences astronomers routinely argue about.
-
Push z to 1 and the discrepancy stops being a correction. v = cz returns exactly c; the relativistic formula returns three-fifths of it.
Answer
The tool prints 721.6 nm, 28 487 km/s and 9.50% of c, with a scale factor of 0.9091 — the universe was 91% of its present size when that light set out. The line to carry away is step 5: at z = 1 the shortcut returns light speed exactly, while the answer is 0.600c. Click the deep-field preset and check it. Galaxies are catalogued at z = 7 and beyond, where cz would hand you seven times light speed — which is not a paradox about relativity, it is a formula being used a very long way outside the regime it was derived in.
-
References (2)
- The distinction between the three horizons the first block separates: T. M. Davis and C. H. Lineweaver, "Expanding Confusion: Common Misconceptions of Cosmological Horizons and the Superluminal Expansion of the Universe." Publications of the Astronomical Society of Australia 21(1), 97–109, 2004.
- The Hâ‚€ value the Hubble radius is computed from: N. Aghanim et al. (Planck Collaboration), "Planck 2018 results. VI. Cosmological parameters." Astronomy & Astrophysics 641, A6, 2020.