Problem solved in full
-
Luminosity, temperature, radius and lifetime of a 21 M☉ star 6 steps
A 21 M☉ star. Get its luminosity, temperature, radius and lifetime from the three power laws, then check whether the three can all be true at once. This is the Rigel state.
-
Luminosity is the steepest of the three relations, and it is why massive stars are so unforgiving. Twenty-one times the mass is nearly two hundred thousand times the light.
-
Surface temperature climbs far more gently — a factor of five for a factor of twenty-one in mass — which is why the main sequence is a long diagonal on the H–R diagram rather than a vertical line.
-
Radius and lifetime come from the remaining two fits. A millionth of the Sun's lifetime is the whole point of the tool: this star will die before the Earth's continents finish rearranging.
-
The lifetime law is the one thing here that is not a fit. Fuel available scales as the mass; fuel burnt per second scales as the luminosity; divide.
-
Now the check. Stefan–Boltzmann is not optional — a star's luminosity is its area times σT⁴ — so the radius and temperature exponents already determine the luminosity exponent.
-
Take the ratio of the two answers for L. It is a clean power of the mass, which tells you the disagreement is structural rather than arithmetic.
Answer
They cannot — the panel's own numbers disagree with Stefan–Boltzmann by a factor of 2.08. That is not sloppiness, it is what chaining fitted exponents costs. L = M⁴, R = M^0.8 and T = 5778 M^0.54 are three separate empirical fits to three separate observations, and Stefan's law demands the third follow from the other two: 4 must equal 2(0.8) + 4(0.54) = 3.76. It does not, and the leftover M^0.24 is exactly the 2.08 you find at 21 M☉. Each fit is fine to 10% over the mass range it was drawn for; multiply three of them and the errors are exponents, not percentages. The physics that survives all of it is the lifetime: fuel goes as M and burn rate as M⁴, so τ ∝ M⁻³, and this star gets a millionth of the Sun's ten billion years.
-
References (2)
- The mass–luminosity relation the tool approximates as L = M⁴: Z. Eker et al., "Interrelated main-sequence mass–luminosity, mass–radius, and mass–effective temperature relations." Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 479(4), 5491–5511, 2018.
- Measured masses and radii the relation is fitted to: G. Torres, J. Andersen and A. Giménez, "Accurate masses and radii of normal stars: modern results and applications." The Astronomy and Astrophysics Review 18(1–2), 67–126, 2009.