Problem solved in full
-
A first order reaction at 298 K with E a = 50 kJ/mol 5 steps
Test the rule that a reaction runs twice as fast for every 10 degrees. The state is first order, with an activation energy Ea = 50 kJ/mol, a pre-exponential factor A = 1013 s−1, and T = 298 K.
-
A barrier height means nothing on its own; it matters only against the thermal energy available, so the two enter as a ratio. Here the barrier is about twenty times RT, and the exponential of minus that ratio is the fraction of collisions arriving with enough energy to cross.
-
One collision in 5.8 × 10⁸ clears the barrier. A counts how often the attempt is made, so the rate constant is a frequency multiplied by a probability — which is why a sluggish collision rate and a low barrier can produce the same k as the opposite pair.
-
First order means the fraction consumed per second does not depend on how much is left, so the half-life is fixed by k alone and by nothing about the starting concentration.
-
Q10 is the same expression evaluated at two temperatures and divided, so A cancels — collision frequency plays no part in temperature sensitivity at all. Combining the two reciprocal temperatures leaves one exponential with T(T + 10) sitting in the denominator.
-
That denominator is the finding: Q10 falls roughly as 1/T², so one unchanging molecule has a different Q10 at every temperature. Running the formula backwards gives the barrier height that would make the doubling exact.
Answer
The tool prints k = 1.720 × 10⁴ s⁻¹, t½ = 4.030 × 10⁻⁵ s and Q10 = 1.93×. The rule of thumb survives here by arithmetic accident: 50 kJ/mol sits just below the 52.9 kJ/mol that makes Q10 exactly 2 at room temperature, and nothing in the chemistry pins activation energies to that value. The rule also carries a temperature that is almost never quoted with it — this same reaction gives 2.13 in a 4 °C fridge and 1.52 in boiling water. So a Q10 measured in cold storage cannot be carried into a fermenter, and the error has a known sign: a cold Q10 always overstates the sensitivity at high temperature. Q10 is a property of a reaction at a temperature, not a property of the reaction.
-
References (2)
- The temperature dependence the tool computes: S. Arrhenius, "Über die Reaktionsgeschwindigkeit bei der Inversion von Rohrzucker durch Säuren." Zeitschrift für Physikalische Chemie 4U(1), 226–248, 1889.
- The Boltzmann factor and the high-energy tail behind it: P. Atkins and J. de Paula, Atkins’ Physical Chemistry, 10th ed., ch. 20–21. Oxford University Press, 2014. ISBN 978-0-19-969740-3.