Lesson
The theory — Gibbs Free Energy & Spontaneity
The Gibbs free energy change of a reaction, ΔG = ΔH − TΔS, is the most work it can deliver at constant temperature and pressure, other than pushing back the atmosphere. A reaction with ΔG < 0 can proceed by itself; one with ΔG > 0 goes the other way; at ΔG = 0 the two directions balance. The standard value fixes the equilibrium constant: ΔG° = −RT ln K. When ΔH and ΔS have the same sign, ΔG changes sign at T = ΔH/ΔS.
What each symbol means
ΔG- the Gibbs free energy change, in kJ per mole of reaction as written. Negative: the products are favoured
ΔS- the entropy change, in J/(mol·K). Its sign is the slope of ΔG against T, with the sign reversed
T- the absolute temperature, in kelvin. Every formula on this page uses it; the Celsius box is for convenience
K- the equilibrium constant, dimensionless: pressures in bar and concentrations in mol/L, each divided by its standard value
- Assumes
- ΔH and ΔS keep their 25 °C values at every temperature. This is the Ellingham approximation, and it is what makes the first panel a straight line. All species are in their standard states, 1 bar for gases, so ΔG here is ΔG° and K is the value that goes with it; a real mixture has a reaction quotient Q, and the reaction runs towards K from wherever Q starts. The ice preset is built differently: its ΔS is ΔH divided by the melting point, which is how an entropy of fusion is measured, so its crossover sits at 0 °C by construction.
- Breaks when
- At high temperature, by an amount the worked problem measures: for limestone the constant-value crossing is 45 degrees too low. And ΔG says nothing about speed. Diamond turning into graphite has ΔG ≈ −2.9 kJ/mol at room temperature, and diamonds last for billions of years, because no pathway at that temperature is fast enough to notice. The Haber process runs at 450 °C, against its own equilibrium, for the same reason in reverse.
Problem solved in full
-
Where limestone really turns, from the hot tables 4 steps
From 25 °C values the page puts limestone's crossover at 843.1 °C, and a real kiln needs about 898 °C. Robie and Hemingway (USGS, 1995) also tabulate each substance at high temperature. At 1100 K, (H − H₂₉₈)/T is 81.61 J/(mol·K) for CaCO₃, 36.97 for CaO and 35.35 for CO₂, and S° is 232.23, 102.88 and 274.51. At 1200 K the six numbers are 85.57, 38.38, 37.06 and 243.46, 107.58, 279.37. Find where ΔG really crosses zero.
-
Heat content first. The products gain 36.97 + 35.35 J/(mol·K) and the carbonate 81.61, so the reaction's enthalpy falls by 9.29 × 1100 J, about 10.2 kJ below its 25 °C value.
-
The entropy of reaction at 1100 K comes straight from the three S° values, and it is 15 J/(mol·K) smaller than at 25 °C.
-
So at 1100 K the reaction still refuses, by 8.905 kJ/mol. Repeating both steps at 1200 K gives ΔG = −5.544 kJ/mol: it goes.
-
ΔG is nearly straight over a hundred kelvin, so the crossing sits 8.905/(8.905 + 5.544) of the way from 1100 K to 1200 K.
Answer
About 1161.6 K, or 888.5 °C. Of the 55 degrees between the page's 843.1 °C and a working kiln, 45.4 are the constant-ΔH-and-ΔS approximation: both fall as the solid heats, and ΔS falls a little faster. The last 9.5 degrees is about what calcite's own ±1.3 kJ/mol uncertainty in ΔfH° allows, so the tables and Smyth and Adams's 898 °C agree as well as the data can. The page's straight line is the right tool for asking which way a reaction goes, and a rough one for asking at exactly what temperature.
-
Learning path
Why a reaction goes
References (3)
- Every limestone figure on the page, and the high-temperature rows the worked problem uses: calcite, lime and carbon dioxide from one compilation, so that the crossover is not moved by mixing tables: R. A. Robie and B. S. Hemingway, Thermodynamic Properties of Minerals and Related Substances at 298.15 K and 1 Bar (10^5 Pascals) Pressure and at Higher Temperatures. U.S. Geological Survey Bulletin 2131, 1995. DOI 10.3133/b2131
- The 898 °C at which calcite's CO2 pressure reaches one atmosphere, which insight block 1 and the worked problem measure the page against: F. H. Smyth and L. H. Adams, "The System, Calcium Oxide-Carbon Dioxide." Journal of the American Chemical Society 45(5), 1923, pp. 1167-1184. DOI 10.1021/ja01658a009
- Ammonia, nitrogen, hydrogen and oxygen are CODATA key values and ozone is NIST-JANAF, each read from its WebBook page (this is ammonia's): P. J. Linstrom and W. G. Mallard (eds.), NIST Chemistry WebBook, NIST Standard Reference Database Number 69. National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg MD. Ammonia, gas-phase thermochemistry.