Problem solved in full
-
Two Great Pyramid coincidences, settled with one number 6 steps
The Great Pyramid: base 230.4 m, height 146.6 m. Get the slant, the areas, the volume and the face angle — then settle the two famous coincidences with one number.
-
Slant height is the hypotenuse of the triangle from the centre of the base to the mid-edge and up to the apex — half the base, not the full base, which is the commonest slip here.
-
The lateral surface is four triangles, each with base s and height ℓ, so 4 × ½sℓ collapses to 2sℓ. Add the base for the total.
-
Volume is one third of the prism, and the third is not an approximation — it is exact for any pyramid on any base.
-
The face angle comes from rise over half-base. The seked is its reciprocal, and that is the number the builders actually worked in.
-
Compare the measured seked with the simplest fraction near it. Five and a half palms per cubit of seven palms is 11/14, and it matches to one part in eight thousand.
-
Now derive the π ratio from that one fraction. It is not an independent fact about the pyramid; it is 8k, and 8 × 11/14 happens to sit 0.04% from 2π.
Answer
Both coincidences are the same coincidence, and it is a builder's fraction: a seked of 11/14. The Egyptians did not specify a slope as an angle; they specified how many palms of horizontal run go with one cubit of rise, and a cubit is seven palms. Choose 5½ palms and the seked, as a pure ratio, is 11/14 = 0.785714 — against the 0.785812 the pyramid actually measures. Everything else follows. Perimeter over height is exactly 8 times the seked, so 8 × 11/14 = 6.28571 against 2π = 6.28319, and the slant-to-half-base ratio comes out at 1.6186 against φ = 1.618034. Neither π nor φ was put in. One rational slope, chosen because it was easy to set out with a rope and a plumb line, produces both to three figures.
-
References (2)
- Insight block 1 — why the factor of 1/3 cannot be shown with scissors: M. Dehn, "Ueber den Rauminhalt." Mathematische Annalen 55(3), 465–478, 1901 — the negative answer to Hilbert's third problem.
- Insight block 3 — the seked, and the 5½ palms of the Great Pyramid: A. B. Chace, The Rhind Mathematical Papyrus, problems 56–60. Mathematical Association of America, 1927–29.