Problem solved in full
-
The period of two clean oscillations from release at rest 7 steps
Released from rest at ΞΈβ = 20Β° and ΞΈβ = 10Β°, with mβ = mβ = 1, lβ = lβ = 1 and g = 9.81, and damping c = 0. Angles this small are not chaotic β the motion is a sum of two clean oscillations. Find the period of each, then decide which of them the cycle marks on the panel are counting.
-
Cut the equations of motion above down to size. Small angles mean sin ΞΈ becomes ΞΈ and cos 2Ξ becomes 1, and the squared-velocity terms are second order in a small amplitude, so they go. Both denominators collapse to 2mβ + mβ β mβ = 2, and what survives is linear and still coupled: neither bob moves without pushing the other.
-
Set a yardstick before solving anything. A single 1 m pendulum swings at Οβ = β(g/l), giving the 2.01 s the panel prints as its period hint and stamps on every cycle mark. Hold on to it, because nothing below is going to equal it.
-
A normal mode is a motion in which both angles oscillate at one shared frequency and keep a fixed ratio. Substitute ΞΈα΅’ = aα΅’ cos Οt and each of the two equations hands you that ratio aβ/aβ, arrived at from opposite ends.
-
The two expressions for one ratio must agree, and setting them equal eliminates both amplitudes. What is left is a quadratic in ΟΒ², and a quadratic has 2 roots. That is where the second period comes from.
-
So this pendulum has 2 periods, 2.62 s and 1.09 s, and the 2.01 s on the cycle marks is neither. It lies between them and belongs to neither one.
-
Each root carries its own shape back. The slow root gives aβ/aβ = +1.414: both bobs swing the same way, the lower one 1.414 times wider. The fast root gives β1.414: they swing in opposition and the joint between them scissors.
-
A start of 20Β° and 10Β° is neither shape, so both modes are running at once. Split it into a slow amplitude A and a fast amplitude B β the top bob needs A + B = 20Β°, the bottom needs β2(A β B) = 10Β° β and the slow mode takes 13.54Β° of the start while the fast one takes 6.46Β°.
Answer
2.62 s and 1.09 s, and their ratio is exactly 1 + β2. An irrational ratio means the 2 modes never come back into step, so the figure the lower bob traces never quite repeats β and this is the tame small-angle case, with no chaos in it anywhere. It also settles what the 2.01 s cycle marks are: a single-pendulum ruler laid against a 2-frequency motion, which is why the angles logged at each mark keep drifting instead of returning to 20.0Β° and 10.0Β°. Push the release to 145Β° and even the 2 frequencies go, because sin 145Β° = 0.5736 while the angle itself is 2.531 rad β wrong by a factor of 4.4, and the linearisation this whole derivation stands on has nothing left to say.
-
References (1)
- Insight block 3 β a rigid arm whose tip beats a free fall: W. F. D. Theron, "The ''faster than gravity'' demonstration revisited." American Journal of Physics 56(8), 736β739, 1988.