Problem solved in full
-
Why the bottom half of a barrel takes 2.4 times as long as the top 8 steps
A 300 mm barrel is filled 1.00 m deep and a 10 mm hole is opened in the bottom. How long does it take to empty, and how much of that time goes on the last half of the water?
-
Two areas carry the whole problem. The barrel's cross-section says what a millimetre of level is worth in litres; the hole's says how fast those litres can get out.
-
The speed at the hole is Torricelli's again, set by the depth still standing above it. The discharge coefficient is there because the jet pinches to about 62% of the hole as it leaves. Multiply by the hole area for the volume per second, then divide by the barrel area for the speed the level drops.
-
The depth is on both sides, so separate it and integrate from full to empty. This is the only calculus in the problem, and the shape of everything below follows from it.
-
Rearranged, that is the drain time. The numbers go in.
-
Stopping the same integral at a depth h instead of at zero, and turning it round, gives the level at any moment. It is a parabola: it reaches zero at T and stays there. A capacitor never quite finishes discharging. A barrel does, because the last of the water is still being pushed by the last of the depth.
-
Set the level to half and solve for the time. It is not half of T.
-
The top half is gone in 29.3% of the run, which leaves the bottom half the other 70.7%. Nothing in that ratio knows the depth, the diameter, the gravity or the coefficient.
-
T carries a square root of H and nothing else about the water, so filling the same barrel to 2.00 m does not double the wait. It multiplies it by 1.414.
Answer
655.4 seconds, and 70.7% of them go on the bottom half. The level falls as H(1 โ t/T)ยฒ, a parabola that reaches empty at a finite time rather than an exponential that only approaches it. Half the water is gone after 29.3% of the run, which leaves the bottom half taking 1 + โ2 = 2.414 times as long as the top. There is no tank anywhere in that number.
-
Learning path
Water out of a tank: one speed, spent two ways
References (1)
- Torricelli's law applied to quasi-steady tank draining kinetics and parabolic depth decay: E. Torricelli, De motu gravium naturaliter descendentium. Florence, 1644.