Problems solved in full
-
Diameter of the Moon covering 0.5181° of sky at 384,400 km away 6 steps
The Moon covers 0.5181° of sky and is 384,400 km away. Work out its diameter, and work out what forgetting the unit would cost you.
-
The formula for a small distant object is size = distance × angle, which is s = rθ with the Moon's distance as the radius. It needs θ in radians.
-
Convert: 0.5181 × π/180 = 0.0090426 radians.
-
Multiply. 384,400 × 0.0090426 = 3,476 km, against a measured mean diameter of 3,474.8 km.
-
Now forget the conversion and multiply by the raw 0.5181. That gives 199,158 km, a Moon most of the way to being a second Earth-Moon distance across.
-
The ratio of the two answers is 57.30, which is 180/π. Every dropped conversion of this kind is out by exactly that, whatever the numbers were.
-
One check before trusting the answer. The formula treats the Moon's diameter as an arc rather than a straight line across it, and at this angle those differ by 12 metres in 3,476 km, or 3 parts in a million. The approximation is not what limits the result.
Answer
3,476 km, and forgetting the radians costs a factor of 57.3. What limits the fourth digit is not the geometry but the pairing. The Moon's distance runs from about 363,300 km to 405,500 km over a month, an 11% swing, and its angular size swings with it. Even a mean angle against a mean distance lands 1.2 km out, which is the gap between the 3,476 above and the measured 3,474.8, because angular size goes as 1/d and the average of a reciprocal is not the reciprocal of the average. Pair that mean angle with tonight's distance instead and you are 190 km out at perigee, with the arithmetic flawless throughout. The equation cannot tell you that the two numbers you fed it came from different moments.
-
-
θ is bracketed by sine and tangent, and not down the middle 6 steps
At 10° the panel prints an arc of 0.174533, a sine of 0.173648 and an error of 0.510%. Work out where the tangent of the same angle falls, and decide whether 0.510% is the best those two numbers can do.
-
Ten degrees is 10 × π/180 = 0.174533 radians, and on a circle of radius 1 the arc is the angle. That is the whole content of s = rθ.
-
The sine comes in a little short at 0.173648. The panel divides the shortfall by the sine and reports 0.510%.
-
The shortfall has a size you can predict. sin θ = θ − θ³/6 + …, so θ − sin θ should be about θ³/6 = 0.000886, against a measured 0.000885.
-
The tangent overshoots by the same kind of term with twice the coefficient: tan θ = θ + θ³/3 + …, giving tan θ − θ = 0.001794. Together, sin θ < θ < tan θ. That bracket is the squeeze which proves the slope of sine at zero is exactly 1 in radians, and the page prints only its lower half.
-
The bracket is not symmetric. The tangent overshoots 2.03 times as far as the sine falls short, so θ sits one third of the way up from sine to tangent rather than halfway.
-
Weight them in that ratio and the cubic terms cancel outright, since 2(−⅙) + ⅓ = 0. (2 sin θ + tan θ)/3 = 0.1745411, out by 8.2 × 10⁻⁶, or 0.0047% — more than a hundred times closer than the sine alone, from the same two numbers.
Answer
The tangent lands at 0.176327, on the far side of the arc, and 0.510% is a long way from the best available. This weighting has a long history under another name: a regular polygon inscribed in a circle has perimeter 2n sin(π/n) and the circumscribed one 2n tan(π/n), the same sine and tangent at θ = π/n, and dividing by the diameter gives the classical bounds on π. At 96 sides those are 3.14103195 and 3.14271460, which on their own settle π to 3.14; combined as (2 × 3.14103195 + 3.14271460)/3 they give 3.14159283 against a true 3.14159265. The tangent has been in the tool's own model all along; only the sine gets a card, because the small-angle rule is what a physics course asks for.
-
Learning path