Problem solved in full
-
Unrolling one turn of a screw thread into a triangle 7 steps
Load Standard Screw: a 3 mm pitch on a 10 mm radius, 1,000 N of load, μ = 0.15. The panel says an ideal advantage of 20.94 and an efficiency of 24.0%. Both come from the same triangle. Find it.
-
Take one full turn of the thread and unroll it. The thread climbs by the pitch while it travels once round the shaft, so it is the hypotenuse of a right triangle whose height is the pitch and whose base is the circumference. A screw is an inclined plane that has been wrapped round a cylinder, and this is that sentence made arithmetic.
-
The slope of that triangle is the helix angle. Under three degrees, which is why a screw feels nothing like a ramp even though it is one.
-
Ideal advantage is the distance you move over the distance the load moves: once round the circumference to advance one pitch.
-
Friction enters as an angle of its own. The friction angle is the slope at which a surface just begins to let go, and adding it to the helix angle is the standard way to fold friction into a screw.
-
The effort follows directly. Rather than 1,000 divided by 20.94, which is 47.8 N, you need four times that.
-
The advantage you actually get is the load divided by that effort, 1,000/199.2 = 5.02. So the efficiency is the ratio of what you got to what the geometry offered.
-
And the same comparison, written with a tangent instead of an angle, tells you whether the screw stays put with no hand on it.
Answer
An ideal advantage of 20.94 from a triangle 3 mm tall and 62.83 mm long, and 24.0% efficiency because friction adds 8.531° to a slope that was only 2.734° to begin with.
Three quarters of the work goes into the thread, and that is not a defect being tolerated — it is the feature being paid for. A machine this bad at giving work back cannot be pushed backwards by its own load, which is precisely what tan λ ≤ μ says: 0.0477 against 0.15, so it self-locks with room to spare. That is why a bolt stays done up with no ratchet, no pawl and no spring, and why a car jack holds a ton in the air while you take your hand off the handle. Switch the mode to Ramp and try to find an angle that self-locks and still gives an advantage of 20: there is none, because on an open ramp the two conditions pull in opposite directions. Wrapping the triangle round a cylinder is what lets a screw have both. -
Learning path