Problems solved in full
-
Why your arm needs 350 newtons to hold a 50 newton weight 6 steps
Load the Biceps Arm preset: a 5 cm effort arm, a 35 cm load arm, 50 N in the hand. The panel says the effort is 350 N and the mechanical advantage is 0.14. Work out where those come from, and then say what the arm gets in return for being built this badly.
-
Everything about a lever comes from one balance. Take moments about the fulcrum: force times distance on one side equals force times distance on the other. That is the whole model, and the rest is arithmetic.
-
Put the numbers in. The load sits 35 cm from the elbow and the biceps pulls only 5 cm from it, so the muscle is at a seven-to-one disadvantage before anything else happens.
-
Mechanical advantage is what you lift over what you pull. It comes out below 1, which means the machine is costing you force rather than saving it. Notice it equals a/b as well: the ratio of the arms, arrived at from the other end.
-
Now the return. Sweep the arm through a small angle and both ends move in proportion to their distance from the fulcrum, so the hand travels b/a times as far as the muscle does. Seven centimetres of hand for every centimetre of contraction.
-
Nothing was lost or gained. Take the load through 1 cm: the muscle does 0.500 J and the weight receives 0.500 J. What changed hands was the split between force and distance.
-
And the disadvantage is not an accident of these numbers. A third-class lever is defined by the effort being applied between the fulcrum and the load, which forces a to be smaller than b, which forces the advantage below 1. There is no third-class lever anywhere that lifts more than you pull.
Answer
350 N, because 50 N acting at 35 cm needs 350 N at 5 cm to balance it, and the advantage of 0.14 is the same ratio inverted. The arm pays seven times the force and receives seven times the speed.
That trade is the reason the design survived. A limb built for mechanical advantage would lift more and move like a crane; muscle is expensive but muscle is also strong, and the scarce thing in catching prey or throwing a spear is hand speed, not force. -
-
A crowbar that turns 300 newtons into 100, and the 400 the pivot takes 6 steps
Load the Crowbar preset: a 150 cm effort arm, a 50 cm load arm, a 300 N lid. Work out the effort, then decide how strong the block you rest the bar on has to be.
-
Moments about the fulcrum settle the effort in one line: 300 N acting at 50 cm is balanced by 100 N at 150 cm. The cards agree, at 100.0 N with an advantage of 3.00, bought with 3.00 cm of hand travel for every centimetre the lid rises.
-
Moments are only half of statics. The bar is not going anywhere, so the forces on it have to sum to zero as well, and there are three of them: your hand, the lid, and whatever the bar is resting on. Nothing on this page computes the third one.
-
On a first-class lever the fulcrum sits between the other two, and both of them press down: you push down on the long end, and the lid pulls down on the short one. So the block underneath pushes up with the sum, 400 N. Your hand feels a third of the lid; the block feels more than all of it.
-
The reaction is L(1 + 1/MA), which always exceeds the load, and the better the lever the closer it settles towards the load from above. A crowbar with a hundredfold advantage still sends 1.01 times the load through its pivot.
-
Second class inverts the arrangement, and the tool has one: the wheelbarrow, 600 N at the same advantage of 3. The load now sits between the fulcrum and the effort and you lift the handles, so the effort points upwards and the axle carries L β E, which is 400 N. Two thirds of what is in the barrow.
-
Third class runs the same formula with an advantage below 1. The biceps preset has MA = 5/35, so 1 β 1/MA is β6 and the reaction is β300 N. The sign is the answer: the elbow end of the forearm is being pulled down with 300 N to hold 50 N in the hand.
Answer
100 N to pull and 400 N through the pivot, a third more than the lid weighs. The bar multiplies your force and the fulcrum absorbs the difference, so the block is the part of the arrangement that has to be sound.
Across all three classes the pivot carries L(1 Β± 1/MA), and the sign in that bracket is the most useful thing the classification tells you. A first-class pivot always takes more than the load, which is why an improvised fulcrum under a crowbar is where the arrangement fails. A second-class pivot always takes less, which is why a wheelbarrow wheel can be light. A third-class pivot takes a force in the opposite direction to the one anyone guesses, and its size is set by the muscle rather than by what is in the hand: 300 N through the elbow to hold a 50 N weight. -
Learning path