Lesson
The theory — The Tennis Racket Theorem
The tennis racket theorem, or intermediate axis theorem: a rigid body whose three principal moments of inertia differ, I1 < I2 < I3, spins stably about the axes of the smallest and the largest moment and unstably about the middle one. For a box those are the axes along its longest side, its shortest side and the side in between. With no torque, a small wobble about the middle axis grows as eλt with λ = ω√((I₂ − I₁)(I₃ − I₂)/(I₁I₃)) until the body turns over, while its angular momentum stays fixed in space. A racket thrown so that its handle makes one full turn comes back with its faces exchanged; in orbit the same motion is called the Dzhanibekov effect, after the cosmonaut who watched a spinning wing nut keep flipping in weightlessness in 1985.
What each symbol means
I₁- the smallest principal moment of inertia; for a box, about the axis along its longest side
I₂- the middle moment: the axis that will not hold a spin
I₃- the largest moment; for a thin flat body it is about the axis through the face, and I₃ = I₁ + I₂
λ- growth rate of a small wobble about the middle axis: the wobble multiplies by e every 1/λ
ε- the starting wobble, the spin about each of the other two axes as a fraction of the main spin
- Assumes
- A rigid body with no torque on it: no air, and no gravity gradient. Thrown on Earth, the centre of mass falls but the rotation about it is the same. The energy leak, when it is on, is a model with exactly two properties, energy out and L unchanged, at a rate this page chose; real damping depends on how the body flexes.
Problem solved in full
-
How clean a throw does a sheet of paper need? 5 steps
A sheet of A4, 210 mm by 297 mm, is spun at 1 rev/s about the axis that runs along its short side, through its centre. Find the ratio of its three moments of inertia, how fast a wobble grows, and how small the starting wobble must be for ten seconds between flips, and for a minute. Press Middle axis, ε 10⁻³ to check the second step.
-
All of a thin sheet's mass lies in one plane. About the axis along its long side the mass is spread across the 210 mm width, so I₁ = m b²/12 with b = 210 mm; about the axis along the short side, I₂ = m a²/12 with a = 297 mm; and about the axis through the face, the perpendicular axis theorem gives I₃ = I₁ + I₂:
-
A-series paper is cut so that a sheet halved has the same shape, which needs a/b = √2, and then the ratio is exactly 1 : 2 : 3; 297/210 is √2 rounded to the millimetre. With ω = 2π rad/s, as in the page's first preset:
-
Between flips the wobble shrinks to about ε and grows back to about 1, so the interval goes as (2/λ) ln(1/ε) plus a constant. The page prints 4.38 s at ε = 10⁻³ and 1.27 s for each further factor of ten. Ten seconds needs
-
A minute needs 55.62 s more than the page's preset gives:
-
For scale, a sheet 0.3 m long whose axis was set true to the width of one atom, 10⁻¹⁰ m, would start with a wobble of about one part in 3×10⁹:
Answer
The moments are 1 : 2.0002 : 3.0002 and a wobble grows at λ = 3.628 s⁻¹. Ten seconds between flips needs a starting wobble of 3.75×10⁻⁸, and a minute needs 1.54×10⁻⁴⁷, solving the exact interval rather than the decade rule. Setting the axis true to an atom's width buys about 12.6 s. No throw keeps a sheet spinning about its middle axis for a minute.
-
Learning path
Rotation and angular momentum
References (3)
- A phone tossed in the air as a free-rotation laboratory: Euler's equations, the instability of the middle axis, and the moments of an iPhone 8 Plus, 1.04, 4.23 and 5.25 ×10⁻⁴ kg·m², computed from its measured mass and dimensions, behind the page's phone preset: M. S. Wheatland, T. Murphy, D. Naoumenko, D. van Schijndel and G. Katsifis, "The mobile phone as a free-rotation laboratory", American Journal of Physics 89, 342–348 (2021). doi:10.1119/10.0003380
- Explorer 1, in 1958, was a very prolate body with four deformable antennas, meant to spin about its least-inertia axis, and refused; a body that loses energy at fixed angular momentum must end in the minimum-energy state, a spin about the maximal-inertia axis: M. Efroimsky, "Relaxation of wobbling asteroids and comets: theoretical problems, perspectives of experimental observation", Planetary and Space Science 49(9), 937–955 (2001). doi:10.1016/S0032-0633(01)00051-4
- Dzhanibekov's wing nut, observed in 1985, flips for ever in Euler's equations; real bodies dissipate, and a torque-free body ends spinning about its major axis, so 'had Dzhanibekov observed his wing nut for a sufficiently long period, he would have found it spinning around the major axis': J. A. de la Torre and P. Español, "Internal dissipation in the Dzhanibekov effect", European Journal of Mechanics A/Solids 106, 105298 (2024). doi:10.1016/j.euromechsol.2024.105298