Lesson
The theory — Capacitors & Stored Energy
A capacitor is two conductors separated by an insulator. Put +Q on one and −Q on the other and a voltage V appears between them; the ratio C = Q/V is the capacitance, in farads. Two flat plates of area A a distance d apart have C = ε₀εᵣA/d. A charged capacitor holds the energy U = ½CV² = Q²/2C. A supply at a fixed V pays QV to move the charge Q, which is twice what ends up stored.
What each symbol means
C- capacitance, in farads: the charge per volt. A farad is enormous; the capacitors on this page are microfarads and picofarads
Q- the charge on each plate, in coulombs, equal and opposite on the two
V- the voltage between the plates. For a supply, the voltage it holds whatever current flows
U- the energy stored in the field between the plates, in joules
εᵣ- relative permittivity of what fills the gap: 1 for vacuum, very close to 1 for air, and the factor by which an insulator raises the capacitance
d- the gap between the plates. Capacitance goes as 1/d, so halving the gap doubles it
N- the number of equal steps the supply climbs in. Each jump is V/N
- Assumes
- Ideal parts: a capacitor with no leakage and no resistance of its own, a supply that holds its voltage exactly, and a resistor that obeys Ohm's law. Each step of the staircase is left to settle for fifteen time constants before the next, which leaves 3 parts in 10 million of it undone. The plates are ideal too: the field between them is taken as uniform and the field that bulges out past the edges is ignored, which is fair while the gap is small compared with the width of the plates. The plate is moved slowly, so the current that flows to or from the battery never heats anything.
Problem solved in full
-
Where to put the tap 6 steps
A 100 µF capacitor has to be charged to 12 V through 1 kΩ, and the power supply has one spare output you can switch to first. How much heat does a single jump to 12 V make? How much if the spare output is 4 V, and how much at 6 V? Where should a single intermediate output sit, and how many equal steps would keep the heat to 1% of the stored energy?
-
One jump first. The supply moves 1.2 mC through 12 V and pays 14.40 mJ; the capacitor keeps ½CV² = 7.200 mJ, so the resistor makes 7.200 mJ of heat. This is the tool with N = 1.
-
A jump of ΔV onto a capacitor costs ½C(ΔV)² in heat, whatever the resistor and whatever voltage the capacitor started from. So a tap at x volts costs two jumps: ½C[x² + (12 − x)²].
-
At 4 V: ½ × 100 µF × (16 + 64) V² = 4.000 mJ. A tap at 8 V gives the same, since the two jumps just swap order.
-
At 6 V: ½ × 100 µF × (36 + 36) V² = 3.600 mJ, half the single jump. Set N = 2 on the tool and the heat row agrees.
-
Where is the best tap? x² + (12 − x)² is smallest where its slope 2x − 2(12 − x) is zero, at x = 6 V, the midpoint. The same argument for any number of jumps: with their sum fixed at V, a sum of squares is smallest when all the jumps are equal, and then it is N(V/N)² = V²/N.
-
So equal steps are the best that steps can do, which is why the tool only offers equal ones, and the heat is the stored energy divided by N. For 1% of 7.200 mJ, N has to reach 100.
Answer
7.200 mJ in one jump, 4.000 mJ via 4 V, 3.600 mJ via 6 V. The middle is the best place for a single tap, and for several taps the best spacing is equal, which leaves heat = ½CV²/N. Keeping it to 1% of the stored energy takes 100 steps, and the step table's last row shows the 72.00 µJ that leaves. The tool stops at equal steps; an unequal set, like the 4 V tap, is always worse, and the sum of squares in step 2 says by how much.
-
Learning path
What is not a resistor
References (2)
- The parallel-plate capacitance and the three forms of the stored energy in the definition and the results table: S. J. Ling, J. Sanny and W. Moebs, University Physics Volume 2. OpenStax. §8.1 "Capacitors and Capacitance" (Equation 8.3) and §8.3 "Energy Stored in a Capacitor" (Equation 8.10).
- Stepwise charging as a real circuit technique, for the last sentence of the first insight: E. J. Carlson and J. R. Smith, "An Analytical Model for Stepwise Adiabatic Driver Energy Consumption." arXiv:2210.16680, 29 October 2022. §1.